Failure to impose public order means Council loses £200,000 in fines for noisy drivers

f2644a73835af216e254d149faccc691

As many residents will recall, acoustic cameras were installed on the A34 bypass near the Whitehall Bridge roundabout towards the end of October 2022.

The noise-activated cameras were purchased and installed as a joint venture between the Police & Crime Commissioner and Cheshire East Highways to crack down on noisy anti-social motorists. Placed on a roundabout approach on the A34 Pendleton Way, between Wilmslow and Alderley Edge, they are monitored, virtually, by Cheshire Police.

Since the installation of the acoustic camera on 21 October 2022 until the 16 April 2024 (when the camera was removed) there were a total of 2,021 activations. An activation of the camera is defined as a situation where a vehicle using the road emits a sound which is over 90 dB (so called 'trigger event').

A breakdown of the incidents, obtained via a Freedom of Information Request, shows they were increasing signifanctly. In the first three months of 2024 there were 447 activations compared with the corresponding months in 2023 when there were 193.

Incidents recorded by the camera could not be used to impose fines, that would depend on Cheshire East introducing a Public Space Protection Order. Had the Council put a Public Space Protection Order in place this would have meant that approximately £200,000 in fines could have been issued generating much needed funds for the cash-strapped council.

Local resident Alan Butler, who spoke at the recent Council meeting told wilmslow.co.uk "After nineteen months Cheshire East failed to initiate the PSPO process despite Cheshire Police's offer to manage both the camera and back-office support for it. The PCC withdrew trial funding and Cheshire East arranged for the camera to be removed in April 2024. An opportunity to improve the lives of residents and benefit from fine proceeds was not acted upon."

Councillor Craig Browne said "Unfortunately officers at Cheshire East Council have been reluctant to begin the process of making a PSPO due to their lack of a "back office" resource to process the fines and deal with any legal challenges.

"Needless to say, I am finding this incredibly frustrating, but will continue to work with the Police & Crime Commissioner to try and persuade officers that this is necessary."

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Comments

Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below.

Mathew Owen
Sunday 28th July 2024 at 2:28 am
Typical incompetence by Cheshire East Council, what do they actually get paid for ?
David Carey
Monday 29th July 2024 at 4:24 am
So far then a waste of time yet the noise still persists.
CE appear to be too concerned with making a total hash of waste collection to be bothered about what their residents want sorting out.
Remind me what do we pay our PCC to do?
Kelvin Briggs
Monday 29th July 2024 at 5:24 am
Perhaps the new Police Commissioner can have a word with the new Cheshire East leader?
Alan Butler
Tuesday 30th July 2024 at 8:25 am
The initial trial period was three months. The PCC funded it for nineteen months while Cheshire East failed to act on a PSPO. Three months later, CE still hadn’t analysed the results.

The camera solution was frustrated by an anonymous employed officer or officers. Power in CE isn’t held by those who we elect.
Jeremy Levy
Tuesday 30th July 2024 at 3:58 pm
The noise from these vehicles is making Wilmslow and Alderley Edge a very unpleasant place to live.
Something serious needs to be done to deal with this problem.
We are really struggling with the noise levels.
Alan Brough
Wednesday 31st July 2024 at 6:35 am
I remember the hi-viz photo opportunity when this “initiative” was launched. We were to be the first council area after Kensington & Chelsea to benefit from this technology.

At a time when CEC is effectively bankrupt and we will inevitably suffer higher Council Tax demands for diminishing services, this catastrophic and negligent waste of our money is particularly hard to swallow.
Kelvin Briggs
Wednesday 31st July 2024 at 9:25 am
Please everyone concerned about the noise and speeding and the indifferent response from Cheshire East, write to our MP. It seems we can’t rely on Cheshire East Council for support.

David Smith
Saturday 17th August 2024 at 6:50 am
Anyone who only 'enjoys' ALDERLEYEDGE.COM might be interested to know this acoustic camera situation [fiasco?] is being strongly aired on sister website WILMSLOW.CO.UK at the link:

https://www.wilmslow.co.uk/news/article/24170/failure-to-impose-public-order-means-council-loses-over-130000-in-fines-for-noisy-drivers?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter1595

So please have your say there too.